Share This:

This is a bit of a long shot, but here goes:

My name is Art Morgan, and I live in San Mateo, California (the northern part of what we call Silicon Valley, near San Francisco).  I was not very interested in genealogy until recently, but I'm a technologist by trade, and when National Geographic came out with a personal DNA test several years ago I couldn't resist trying it.

The early tests did not tell you much - they could verify relationships within 3 or 4 generations, and give you an idea of what continents your ancestors where from. However, over time the tests have gotten much better, and I've now taken about 10 different tests, focusing mainly on Y-DNA tests.  Y-DNA tests analyze DNA along your paternal line, which make them particularly useful if you are trying to trace your surname back to your country and region of origin. 

My father has been working on genealogy of our Morgan family for a couple decades now, and has documented our Morgan line to a James Morgan, born 1755 in Virgina, died 1823 in Wayne County, Ohio. Before that we have a brick wall, though there is fairly good evidence that James' father's name was John Morgan.  William is also a likely given name for his ancestors, as James had a brother named William.

We had always assumed that our Morgan ancestors had come from Wales, due mainly to the fact that the name is so common there.  But as I did more detailed DNA tests and the matches started comming back I noticed that most of my close matches were with Irish names.  Names like Kelley, Dial, Butler, Carroll, and Manning are among my closest matches.  And even the matches that sound more like English names are found in Ireland, like Mitchell and Payne.  With the help of several DNA researchers I eventually realized that my ancestors were most likely from Western Ireland, and must have lived there for at least 500 years, and perhaps much longer, before emigrating to the American colonies in the late 1600s or early 1700s.  

Earlier this year I had an Irish researcher Dr. Tyrone Bowes do an analysis of our DNA results (attached).  Based on name frequency of our matches in census data, he estimates the most likely area for our "genetic homeland" to be northern County Galway, near Glenamaddy.  Using Griffith's Valuation data I have found some likely areas for relatives, such as Croaghill near Williamstown.  Of course, all of this is quite speculative, but I think it's fairly safe to conclude that my Morgan ancestors lived in Connacht, as opposed to Ulster or Leinster where the name Morgan is much more common.

Combining what we know about James Morgan in the 1700s and our new knowledge that our ancestor came from Connacht, we think now that our first Morgan ancestor in the colonies likely came from Ireland to Maryland, Virginia, or Philadelphia, perhaps as an indentured servant.  Digging up records on indentured servants is challenging, but we have a few leads from court records about a few boys with the surname Morgan who were forced to be servants without indenture in Maryland and Virginia in the late 1600s and early 1700s.  We still have more research to do to see if we can tie any of them to James.

So what am I looking for from the good members of IrelandXO? Basically I am looking for men with the surname Morgan who can trace their family history back to at least the 1700s, living in Connacht.  If anyone like this is willing to take a DNA test, I am willing to pay for the test.  The test is simple and painless - you just swab your inner cheek for some saliva and skin cells, and mail the sample in a small vial to the test lab.  FamilyTreeDNA has test on sale now through the end of the year, so I'm hoping to find someone who would do this in the next month.

As I said at the outset this is a long shot, but if you know any Morgan men who might be interested in solving a 300 year old mystery and finding their long-lost cousins in America, please let me know!  

Friday 29th Nov 2013, 08:54PM

Message Board Replies

  • Hi Art,

    Here are a few ideas for your long shot.

    The Irish phone book is available online at www.eircomphonebook.ie/

    If you search RESIDENTIAL for Morgan in County Galway you'll get 37 matches. I suggest you copy your spiel from above and send it to all of them if you don't get a response from this site. (We have had some success with this approach).

    There is a site www.rootsireland.ie/ on which you can search for Morgans births, marriages and deaths

    I searched births/baptisms for James Morgan born 1800 + - 20 years in Galway and got 1 match: 1820

    I went back to 1700 and searched for James Morgan every 20 years but the above was the only 1 so could he be your man? You need to purchase credit to view the full record but it SHOULD have parents' names (some don't). I checked the parish and it was Tuam R C.

    The Tithe Applotments are free to search online and have 32 Morgans in Galway 1823-35

    I admire your detective work with the DNA!

    Col

     

    ColCaff, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘

    Friday 29th Nov 2013, 11:55PM
  • Col,

    Thanks for the suggestions!  I had not heard of the Tithe Applotments; that allows me to go a little further back than the Griffith's Valuation, which I have been using.  Both are at least 100 years after my ancestor emigrated to the American colonies, but the Morgan's who turn up there could well be descendents of my emigrant ancestor.  I will also start using rootsireland.ie, even though I hate the way it charges you for every search.

    Regarding the phone book, I just wanted to ask for some clarification: I found the 37 matches that you mention, but I only see phone numbers -- no emails. Are you suggesting that it sometimes works to call people from the phone book, or is there some other contact info that I'm missing?

    Thanks,

    Art

     

    Saturday 30th Nov 2013, 02:34AM
  • Hi Art

    I meant send letters to the addresses given in the phone book with your information, request & contact details

    Just draught one up & fire it off to them all - who knows - you might hear an Irish accent on the end of the phone or get an email in reply. It's a hefty stamp bill but may pay off.

    Col

    ColCaff, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘

    Saturday 30th Nov 2013, 03:27AM
  • Got it - I will try that.  It sounds like an adventure :-)

    Thanks again,

    Art

    Saturday 30th Nov 2013, 07:17PM
  • Hello Glenamaddy Members, 

    Hope your 2014 year is getting off to a great start.
    Im creator and administrator of this group Glenamaddy, County Galway, Ireland on Facebook.
    Im also Parish Administrator for Glenamaddy, Galway on the Ireland Reaching Out XO, The Reverse Genealogy Programme.

    This is a great resource to you for genology research with many success stories of people connecting with there relatives in Glenamaddy.

    Erik

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/71896753431/

    Tuesday 4th Feb 2014, 03:34PM
  • Hello,

     

    I read your message with interest. Strangely my surname is Carroll and my great grandmother's name was Mangan/Manning (used interchangeably). A Michael Morgan from a townland called Gurtyhard in Galway (possibly near Meelick, or Ahascragh in Galway) was a prisoner during 1798 here and died from his wounds. I took a particular interest in that name as the details - available in the National Archives here - fitted a family story passed on through the generations. I have been unable to prove that he is related, there being nobody alive to ask! I have had the Carroll DNA done through my brother - do you know if your DNA connection to the Carrolls is to the elycarroll subgroup? Looking forward to your reply, Deirdre Carroll, Dublin, Ireland.

    Deirdre Carroll

    Friday 15th May 2015, 07:18PM
  • Deirdre,

    It's been quite awhile since I made that post and a lot has transpired since then, so I thank you for reaching out.  You bring up several points that are interesting to me, and could indicate some overlaps in our lineage.

    First, I wasn't aware that Mangan and Manning were related surnames.  Can you explain about that a bit more? Where did your grandmother's relatives live, and when was the name changed?  The reason this is interesting to me as that in addition to the Manning who is a pretty close match in my STR matches, I am fairly closely related via SNP testing to a group of people who are descended from a man named John Mangum, who was an early immigrant to Virginia (see http://home.comcast.net/~lynn.parham/DNA4.htm).  The Mangum family researchers aren't sure about this yet, but my theory is that the name Mangum came from the Irish surname Mangan, or some earlier variant.  It's also interesting that Mangan, Mangum, and Morgan are all somewhat similar.

    The Carrolls in my Y-DNA STR results are not genetically very close to to the Ely Carroll.  I am in a haplogroup called A19, underneath Z253, which is parallel to the Z16281 haplogroup of the Ely Carroll according to this website that I found: https://www.familytreedna.com/groups/elycarroll/about. 

    However, the geographic orgins of the Ely Carroll in Ireland (which I understand to be centered in Offally and northern Tipperary) overlap quite nicely with some of the area where I think some of my Morgans may have lived.  So it's possible that my connection with Carrolls is due to what genetic genealogists call a non-paternal event, or NPE.  

    I would be interested to know more about the Michael Morgan you refer to.  I am in correspondence with a Michael Morgan who lives near Nenagh, and he may be a descendant, especially if it was near Meelick, Galway.

    I should also mention that research and testing since my original post indicate that the Connaught/Glenamaddy assumption was most likely incorrect.  More recent matches seem to indicate that my ancestors were mostly east of the river Shannon, likely in the area from Longford to Westmeath to Offally and northern Tipperary.

    Please respond with more info when you have a chance.  If you would prefer, you can email me.  It's often useful to post things online since others may come across it and chime in, but I understand that are hard to post or better to keep private.

    Art

     

    Saturday 16th May 2015, 04:44PM

Post Reply